Auto Insurance Providers

Car insurance carriers and coverage options.

37 providers

Sort:Top rated|A–ZNationwide only

Amica Mutual Insurance

Consistently top-rated auto insurer known for dividend policies that return a portion of premiums to policyholders.

4.8BBB A+Lincoln, RI

USAA

Top-rated insurer exclusively for military members, veterans, and their families. Consistently highest customer satisfaction.

4.8BBB A+Nationwide

NJM Insurance

New Jersey's largest private passenger auto insurer, known for exceptional customer service and competitive rates.

4.7BBB A+West Trenton, NJ

Auto Club of Southern California

AAA SoCal's insurance arm, providing auto coverage exclusively to Southern California with legendary roadside assistance.

4.5BBB A+Costa Mesa, CA

Wawanesa Insurance

Canadian-based mutual insurer with a strong West Coast presence, known for competitive rates for safe drivers.

4.5BBB A+San Diego, CA (US HQ)

CSAA Insurance (AAA)

AAA member company providing auto insurance across California, Nevada, and Utah with exclusive member benefits.

4.4BBB A+Walnut Creek, CA

North Carolina Farm Bureau

North Carolina's leading auto insurer by market share, providing affordable coverage through a statewide network of agents.

4.4BBB ARaleigh, NC

Germania Insurance

Texas-only insurer since 1896. Local agents, competitive rates, and deep knowledge of Texas-specific coverage needs.

4.3BBB A+Brenham, TX

Kentucky Farm Bureau

Kentucky's largest property and casualty insurer, serving members with affordable rates through local agents statewide.

4.3BBB ALouisville, KY

Plymouth Rock Assurance

Regional auto insurer serving the Northeast with innovative technology and personalized pricing.

4.3BBB AWoodbridge, NJ

State Farm

Verified

America's largest auto insurer with local agents nationwide. Known for excellent customer service and bundling discounts.

4.3BBB A+Nationwide

Donegal Insurance

Mid-Atlantic mutual insurer with over 130 years of service, known for personalized agent relationships.

4.2BBB AMarietta, PA

GEICO

Verified

Direct-to-consumer insurer known for competitive rates and 24/7 customer service. "15 minutes could save you 15%."

4.2BBB A+Nationwide

Texas Farm Bureau Insurance

Verified

Member-owned Texas insurer with competitive rates. Requires Farm Bureau membership.

4.2BBB A+Waco, TX

The Hartford

Verified

AARP-endorsed insurer specializing in drivers 50+. Offers RecoverCare and lifetime renewability.

4.2BBB A+Nationwide

Nationwide

Verified

Full-service insurer with SmartRide and SmartMiles programs. "On your side" since 1926.

4.1BBB A+Nationwide

Progressive

Verified

Innovative insurer with Name Your Price tool and Snapshot usage-based program. Great for comparing rates.

4.1BBB A+Nationwide

Texas Mutual Auto Insurance

Austin-based Texas Mutual is one of the largest Texas-only insurance carriers. Known for exceptional customer service and competitive rates for Lone Star State drivers.

4.1BBB AAustin, TX

Travelers Auto Insurance

One of Americas oldest insurers. IntelliDrive telematics and Responsible Driver Plan for accident forgiveness.

4.1BBB A+Nationwide

Allstate

Major insurer with "Mayhem" campaigns. Offers Drivewise telematics and Claim Satisfaction Guarantee.

4.0BBB A+Nationwide

Farmers Insurance

Agent-based insurer with strong presence in Texas. Known for Signal telematics and bundling discounts.

4.0BBB ANationwide

Lemonade Car Insurance

AI-powered insurtech with instant quotes and claims. Giveback program donates unused premiums.

4.0BBB ANationwide

Root Insurance

Verified

Mobile-first insurer using smartphone telematics for personalized rates based on driving behavior.

4.0BBB A-Nationwide

Safeco Insurance

Liberty Mutual subsidiary through independent agents. RightTrack telematics savings up to 30%.

4.0BBB A+Nationwide
Page 1 of 2