Helping You calculate

Back to Blog

The Hidden $3,000: How Much You're Really Overpaying

Most Americans overpay thousands every year on electricity, internet, insurance, and more without realizing it. Here's where your money is going.

MonthlyMate Team
January 25, 2026
5 min read
Share:

Quick test: When's the last time you compared your electricity rate? Your internet price? Your insurance premium?

If it's been over a year, you're probably leaving money on the table.

$2,000-$4,000
Average yearly overpayment on home services

The Annual Overpayment Breakdown

| Service | Yearly Overpayment | Monthly | |---------|-------------------:|--------:| | โšก Electricity | $360 | $30 | | ๐ŸŒ Internet | $240 | $20 | | ๐Ÿš— Auto Insurance | $480 | $40 | | ๐Ÿ  Home Insurance | $300 | $25 | | ๐Ÿ“ฑ Mobile Plan | $420 | $35 | | ๐ŸŽฌ Streaming | $180 | $15 | | ๐Ÿ›ก๏ธ Home Security | $240 | $20 | | TOTAL | $2,220 | $185 |

And that's just the average. Some folks leave a lot more on the table.


Why We Overpay (It's Not Your Fault)

The system is literally designed to confuse you.

1. The Introductory Rate Trap

Remember that $49.99/month internet deal? Check your current bill.

It's probably $89.99 now. That "introductory rate" expired 18 months ago.

โš ๏ธ

73% of consumers don't realize their rates have increased after promotional periods end.

2. The Fine Print Maze

That "5.9ยข/kWh" electricity plan? Here's what they don't tell you upfront:

  • Plus delivery charges
  • Plus TDU fees
  • Plus $9.95 base charge
  • Minimum 1,000 kWh or rate adjusts
  • Promotional rate for first 3 months only
  • Then 12.4ยข/kWh

Actual cost: 11-13ยข/kWh

3. The Hassle Factor

Even knowing you're overpaying, switching feels like a chore:

  • Research providers: 30 min
  • Compare plans: 1 hour
  • Sign up: 20 min
  • Cancel old service: 15 min on hold
  • Set up new service: 20 min
  • Update autopay: 10 min

Total: 2-3 hours per service.

Most people rationally decide that's not worth the hassle.


Where Your Money Actually Goes

โšก Electricity

Real example:

  • User paying: 14.2ยข/kWh on expired plan
  • Better option: 9.8ยข/kWh with same provider
  • Savings: $528/year for identical electricity

๐ŸŒ Internet

Real example:

  • User paying: $85/month for 200 Mbps + $15 router rental
  • Better option: $55/month for 300 Mbps (own router)
  • Savings: $360/year plus faster speeds

๐Ÿš— Insurance

Real example:

  • User with same company for 6 years: $2,100/year
  • Same coverage, different company: $1,400/year
  • Savings: $700/year for identical coverage
๐Ÿ’ก

Insurance companies count on you not shopping around. Customers who switch save an average of $400/year on auto insurance alone.


Quick Wins You Can Do Today

The 10-Minute Bill Audit

Pull up your last statements for:

  • โ˜ Electricity
  • โ˜ Internet
  • โ˜ Auto insurance
  • โ˜ Mobile plan

Write down what you're paying. Awareness is step one.

The Expiration Check

Look for "promotional" or "introductory" language. If your rate "locked in" more than 12 months ago, it probably isn't locked anymore.

The Retention Call

Call your provider: "I'm thinking of switching to [competitor] because they're offering [price]. Can you match that?"

You'd be surprised how often they say yes.


The Compound Effect

What if you saved $200/month on home services?

| Timeframe | Total Saved | What You Could Do | |-----------|------------:|-------------------| | 1 Year | $2,400 | Nice vacation | | 3 Years | $7,200 | Emergency fund | | 5 Years | $12,000 | Down payment boost | | 10 Years | $24,000 | College fund |

Invested at 7% returns, $200/month becomes $34,000 in 10 years.


The Easier Way

โŒ Before
  • Hours of research
  • Confusing comparison websites
  • "I guess this one's fine?"
  • Probably still overpaying
โœ… After
  • 2-minute signup
  • M-8 does the research
  • Clear results in your inbox
  • Actual savings, clearly explained

Let M-8 audit your bills. Tell us your address, pick your services, and see exactly where you can save. No commitment. No credit card. No spam.


The best time to stop overpaying was yesterday. The second best time is right now.

โ€” The MonthlyMate Team

MonthlyMate Team

The MonthlyMate team is dedicated to helping you save money on essential home services. We research, compare, and deliver insights so you can make informed decisions.

Found this helpful?
Share:

Ready to Start Saving?

Let M-8 find the best deals on your home services. It only takes a minute to get started.